
Picture by Mischa Majithia.
We live in a generation that are terrified of commitment and the idea of love, yet we are absolutely obsessed with reading about it. Situationships, dating apps and ghosting have become modern day romance staples whereas fictional men are being worshipped online for remembering a woman’s coffee order. Pastel book covers are taking over bookshops and Jude Bellingham has become the internet’s latest romantic ideal. Somewhere along the way, romance novels have gone from being guilty pleasures to cultural phenomena; falling in love has become fashionable again. So, at a time when real-life relationships can feel increasingly complicated, why do we desperately want to read about people falling in love?
Romance novels seem to have a gradual cultural rebranding. Novels in this genre were something encouraged to be hidden, often associated with being a ‘guilty pleasure’. They would not usually be advertised loudly especially because of the book cover. Many older novels in this genre could be easily identified due to the nature of the cover for example, shirtless men and explicit images, however with recent books, there has been a noticeable change with the use of cartoon images and a mix of vibrant and pastel colours. These expressive book covers do still exist; there has just been a noticeable change in publishing trends.
Additionally, BookTok has driven a lot of this transformation, novels have been given a community to be analysed, romanticised and be recommended to millions all over the world. Books such as Ali Hazelwood’s The Love Hypothesisand Hannah Grace’s Icebreaker are suddenly conversation starters and have found their own manic audience where the fictional men have become love interests in their own light. TikTok currently reports more than 85 million posts using #BookTok, with the community growing 65% year-on-year, and says 51% of 16-25 year old readers discover new books through TikTok. Reading used to be seen as a niche experience, especially when reading romance novels. However, thanks to TikTok it has increasingly become something to publicly celebrate where readers are able to share reactions and debate characters. Despite there being a small community of readers on YouTube, BookTok may be able to explain how romance has become socially acceptable but the question on why we are so drawn to them remains unexplained.
Perhaps the appeal towards romance novels stems from something that modern-dating can’t provide and that’s certainty. In this day and age, dating and relationships requires an emotional investment in one another, trusting the process without knowing if feelings are reciprocated. You put your heart out and risk rejection or uncertainty. Dating apps and situationships have created a culture where nobody’s relationship intentions seem clear anymore. This strongly contrasts fictional relationships, as real-life relationships don’t come with a guaranteed happy ending. In the conventional romance genre, readers know that the couple will end up together. They can count on the idea that they know the couple will face misunderstandings and hurdles but in the end get over it. Readers experience the thrill behind the uncertainty of falling in love knowing that everything will be ok. The predictability of a romance novel is not necessarily a weakness, it is the very thing that is comforting. Readers get to experience the highs and lows of a relationship without having to face personal consequences like the character, whilst becoming obsessed and reassured by the promise of a happy ending. We as readers are able to become emotionally invested without the worrying stress of whether it will it work out. The absence of heartbreak isn’t what makes it so appealing, maybe it is the reassurance that the heartbreak won’t have the final say.
Yet, the appeal lies far beyond the guaranteed happy ending. Romance novels aren’t just popular because the fictional men are attractive or the excitement of the way the characters treat each other are what draws readers in. The readers may be drawn to each characters’ emotional availability and attentiveness where small acts of affection will be just as appreciated as drastic declarations of love. Underneath all the obsessions with men and physical attraction, there is a desire to be understood, heard and chosen, especially when we are at our most vulnerable. Something that is so ordinary. This is where the appeal lies. Romantic novels offer a safe space where readers can explore all sorts including sexual intimacy or emotional depth. Coming from unrealistic circumstances, doesn’t make having the desires themselves unrealistic.
When fictional relationships paint a perfect picture of love, you have to wonder whether this can change what we expect in real life. These madeup men are often portrayed as always being a “10/10” and attentive, somehow always remembering the smallest details. Ordinary relationships are then just disappointing against those standards. This being said, some novels contain tropes of jealousy, possessiveness or controlling behaviour which has been taken and seen as extreme love and devotion. For example, It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover explores themes such as domestic abuse but due to the popularity and presentation of romance, it has almost romanticised the abuse and caused arguments on how serious issues are presented and then discussed. I can see how just because you depict abuse, it doesn’t necessarily mean supporting it, however there are questions on how readers interpret these relationships.
People who read fiction know that books are an over-exaggerated fantasy. Readers are capable of enjoy a good book and knowing that they shouldn’t expect to experience the fictional world created or use it as a guide to their everyday life. After all, we don’t watch superhero films and then expect our daily commute to include flying over the city. So why would romance fiction readers expect any different? Maybe the problem doesn’t lie in the fact that romance novels are unrealistic, maybe it’s the stereotypes associated with romance readers that are the issue.
Who knows? Maybe that is the beauty of a romance novel. We know that real life relationships do not have guaranteed happy endings or perfectly timed confessions and gestures but why should that mean we can’t enjoy reading about them. Maybe we are drawn to romance because we get to escape into a world where love works out. Not because we expect intimate relationships, but rather, for 400 pages we get to believe in a happy ending.

